Not all qualified intermediaries are created equal — and the gap between the cheapest option and a properly bonded, attorney-led firm can cost investors dearly. A failed exchange, whether from a missed deadline, improper documentation, or a QI who mishandles funds, can result in the full capital gains tax bill hitting all at once, potentially consuming 20-40% of an investor's gains depending on their state and federal tax bracket.
The role of a qualified intermediary is deceptively simple to describe: hold the exchange proceeds, prepare the exchange documents, and release funds according to IRS rules. In practice, it requires precise legal knowledge of Treasury Regulation 1.1031, meticulous fund-control procedures, and constant coordination with title companies, escrow officers, and lenders across jurisdictions with different closing customs.
'Commodity' QIs — firms that treat the role as a simple pass-through paperwork service — often cut corners in ways that don't show up until it's too late. Warning signs include commingled exchange funds instead of individual, FDIC-insured accounts per client; no requirement for dual signatures before funds are released; unclear or informal identification procedures; and support staff without direct legal training in 1031 rules.
Before hiring a QI, ask these ten questions: (1) Is our exchange fund held in an individual FDIC-insured account, or commingled with other clients' funds? (2) Are two authorized signatures required to release funds? (3) Is the firm bonded and insured, and can they provide proof? (4) Who personally reviews our identification and exchange documents — a licensed attorney or a call-center employee? (5) How many exchanges has this specific team completed? (6) What is the firm's audit history? (7) Can they handle reverse or improvement exchanges if our deal structure changes? (8) How quickly do they respond to time-sensitive closing requests? (9) Do they coordinate directly with our title company, or leave that step to us? (10) What happens to our funds if the QI firm itself faces financial trouble?
The answers matter because a 1031 exchange is, at its core, a legal transaction with an unforgiving set of deadlines and technical requirements. An attorney-led team doesn't just process your paperwork — they anticipate problems specific to your property type, your state, and your closing timeline before those problems can jeopardize your deferral.
Securitas 1031 was built around this exact standard: individually FDIC-insured accounts for every client, dual-signature fund release, full bonding and insurance, and a team led by attorneys who have personally overseen more than 4,000 exchanges. When your gains are on the line, the qualified intermediary you choose should be the least risky part of the transaction — not the most.
Have Questions About Your Exchange?
Talk to a 1031 expert with no obligation to move forward.
Start My Exchange
